Recently, I watched the 2013 documentary Blackfish, directed by Gabriela Cowperthwaite, which explores the controversial practice of keeping orcas (commonly known as killer whales) in captivity, particularly within the SeaWorld parks. The film, centered on the story of Tilikum, an orca involved in the deaths of three people, including trainer Dawn Brancheau, sparked deep reflections on the ethics of animal captivity. Moreover, it has significantly impacted my approach to research, pushing me to think critically about animal conservation, public education, and the role of zoos and marine parks.
In this blog post, I will reflect on how Blackfish shaped my understanding of orcas in captivity and how it relates to my broader research on animal welfare and interactive design solutions for raising public awareness.
The Tragic Story of Tilikum
The core of Blackfish revolves around Tilikum, a male orca captured off the coast of Iceland in 1983 and transferred between different marine parks, including SeaWorld Orlando, where he spent most of his life. What the film effectively conveys is not just the tragedy of the fatal incidents involving Tilikum, but the systemic issues surrounding orca captivity. Through interviews with former trainers, scientists, and experts, the film paints a grim picture of how these intelligent, social creatures suffer both physically and mentally when confined in small tanks for entertainment purposes.
Blackfish highlights several key points:
- Psychological Impact: Orcas are highly social animals, often living in complex family groups in the wild. The film demonstrates how the isolation and separation from family members can lead to severe psychological distress for orcas in captivity. This stress, Blackfish argues, contributes to the aggressive behaviors observed in Tilikum, behaviors that are rarely, if ever, seen in the wild.
- Physical Deterioration: In captivity, orcas are kept in tanks that are a fraction of the size of their natural habitats. This confinement leads to physical issues, such as collapsed dorsal fins, which affect the majority of captive orcas but are rarely seen in wild populations. The film also emphasizes the lower life expectancy of captive orcas, contrasting SeaWorld’s public claims that orcas live just as long in captivity as they do in the wild.
- Deceptive Practices: One of the more shocking revelations in Blackfish is how marine parks like SeaWorld have historically provided the public with misleading information about orcas, including exaggerated claims about their well-being in captivity. The documentary exposes the commercial motives behind the captivity industry, especially through the use of captive orcas in breeding programs, including Tilikum, despite his involvement in multiple fatal incidents.
Ethical Concerns and the Role of Zoos
Watching Blackfish stirred a deeper contemplation of the ethical dilemmas surrounding the captivity of large, intelligent animals like orcas. One of the most impactful aspects of the documentary is its ability to humanize the orcas, showing how these magnificent creatures suffer in confinement. The personal stories of former trainers also highlight the moral conflict many employees faced when they realized the harmful impacts of captivity on these animals.
For me, the documentary reinforced the notion that captivity, particularly in environments that prioritize entertainment over education, is inherently problematic. It aligns with my earlier reflections from a zoo visit where I observed the distress and unnatural behavior of other captive animals like primates, lions, and dolphins. The primary takeaway here is that traditional zoos and marine parks are often ill-equipped to provide the complex environments that these animals need to thrive. Instead of truly educating the public about the animals‘ natural behaviors and habitats, these facilities often present a highly edited, commodified version of wildlife that glosses over the harsh realities of captivity.
Inspiration for Further Research
One of the most powerful effects Blackfish had on me is its ability to inspire further learning and action. Orcas have always fascinated me, but this documentary deepened my interest in studying them, particularly in their natural environments. It became clear to me that the only way to truly understand these animals is to observe them where they belong: in the wild. Blackfish reinforced the idea that captivity not only deprives orcas of their freedom but also deprives us, as the public, of the chance to witness their authentic behavior.
This idea directly impacts my master’s research, which focuses on public education and the role of interactive design in raising awareness about animal welfare. The film highlights the need for alternatives to traditional zoos and marine parks—alternatives that don’t rely on confinement but instead use technology to educate the public. Inspired by this, I am now exploring ways to design interactive storytelling experiences that allow people to learn about orcas and other wild animals in a more ethical and impactful way. One possibility is the creation of virtual reality exhibits where visitors can experience orcas’ natural behaviors in their expansive ocean habitats, learning about their social structures, communication methods, and the environmental threats they face, without the ethical implications of captivity.
In addition to VR, interactive installations in public spaces could be another avenue for teaching the public about the lives of these animals. For example, an interactive exhibit could allow users to explore the migration patterns of wild orcas, offering a dynamic way to engage with and learn about their natural environments and conservation needs. The key here is to move away from the traditional zoo model and toward experiences that are both educational and ethically responsible.
Orca Captivity: A Catalyst for Change
Ultimately, Blackfish is more than just a documentary; it is a call to action. It not only exposes the ethical and moral issues inherent in keeping orcas in captivity, but it also challenges the public to rethink their relationship with animals in entertainment settings. For me, the film has provided a significant impulse for my own research, pushing me to explore innovative, technology-driven solutions that prioritize education, conservation, and empathy for wild animals.
As I continue to develop my master’s thesis, I intend to focus more on how we can use interactive design to foster a deeper understanding of animals like orcas in their natural habitats. By creating immersive, educational experiences, we can inspire a new generation to value and protect these animals without contributing to their suffering in captivity.
Further Reading
Blackfish – Wikipedia
Doku „Blackfish“: Warum ein Wal seinen Menschen tötete – WELT
Tierquälerei : TUI streicht Ausflüge zu Delfin- und Orca-Shows – WELT
